Monday, November 16, 2026

As a Gigging Musician: How Often Do You Still Make Mistakes? (Answering a User Question)


A thread came up the other day where a user asked a question, and I thought it was a great one to share...

The user asked:

"How Often Do You Still Make Mistakes?

This includes also those who would be good enough to do serious gigs

Edit: Mistakes mean wrong chord, off beat playing and missing your part or being too early, wrong chord voicing (including fucking up a bare chord), playing in the wrong key, having an off day where bends are all too sharp for example, not getting into the rhythm properly etc, maybe even forgetting how to play a section or song entirely"


Even the most godlike players out there have always had an off-night or made the occasional mistake (hell, I just saw Cheap Trick live a couple months ago and Rick was just "whatever", making obvious--and sometimes quite atrocious--mistakes left and right and still having a great time doing it). It's called "being human". And even on recordings, I often will leave a minor hiccup with an instrumental or vocal part unless it's just really, really awful, because it reminds the listener they're not listening to some AI-generated slop and are in fact listening to a real person playing/singing. If someone makes a mistake, laughs it off and keeps playing their asses off, it shows good character and a certain professionalism, and makes me root for the performer a little more.

What I DON'T like (i,e, hate with fiery passion) is when I see folks onstage with iPads or binders full of chord charts, lyrics, etc. as crutches and they're STILL not singing/playing the parts correctly. It's perfectly acceptable in my opinion for someone who is just performing and not relying on assistance to make some mistakes, but when someone turns a band performance into something akin to a karaoke night and is still hosing it, they need to go back to open-mic-night until they're ready to put the work in. I unfortunately have even been in multiple bands where one or more members couldn't make it through a single song without their music/lyric references in front of them. Even the most "pRoFeSsIoNaL" band I've played in (meaning higher-paying gigs with management and "contracts" for gigs) was queerly-centered around a vocalist/keyboardist who, despite her cartoonishly-high level of self-importance and entitlement, couldn't even get through a single song without her iPad of music and lyrics. And even with a lot of the shitty bar bands I've been in over the last decade and a half, at least one member has had to rely on their "cheat sheets" to do the gig, which I always thought was hack as fuck.

There are basic fundamentals you simply CANNOT skimp on, like knowing your parts, paying attention to what the other musicians are playing and making sure you're in tune, those are non-negotiable. You just have to commit to learning the material.

And brain farts WILL happen every once in a while. Playing the wrong chord-voicing isn't a big deal, as long as you have the root chord right (so long as you learn from it and don't do it the whole song--again, comes with the "learning" part). If you're "forgetting" sections regularly though, you're either not playing the songs enough, or you need to stop 2 beers earlier.

Improper bends is more of a basic technique flaw, and that's something you need to just practice on your own until you feel confident every time--you'll still occasionally flub one, but 95% of the time, you need to be able to do a proper bend and it should be a combination of tactile feel and hearing the note. I literally used to sit around practicing bends and vibrato technique while watching TV or sitting at my desk at the office whenever I could, and I've got that Paul Kossoff/Angus Young style control and vibrato technique down perfectly...FINALLY. But it takes work, but worth it. Because bad bends can make an otherwise-decent player sound like they're incompetent. Just takes determination and PRACTICE.

"Off beat playing" or "missing/coming in early/late" are absolutely fundamental things you need to work hard on. Whether it's nerves or just not having really learned the song, fix it. Let the motivation to not embarrass yourself force you to commit those song parts to memory, and if that means you can't go out to the bar to hang out with your buddies tonight or you have to skip some other trivial social activity because you need to really work on your parts, show yourself the respect to do it. A couple gigs back we let this really cute gal come up and do a song with one of the bands I play in, and not only did she come in way too early (completely ignoring a signature guitar melody that happens before each verse), she got off beat as well, and it looked and sounded REALLY amateurish and bad. She didn't have a bad voice, but she couldn't follow cues or wasn't paying attention, and it was secondhand embarrassing. Separate yourself from the karaoke kweens.

Everyone shits their pants at some point, but if you put the time in, you can mitigate the damage. Basically, if you have this many issues you're not confident about, you kind of answer your own question (that you're not quite ready yet). If it was just one or two of those concerns, I'd say you were just being hard on yourself, but it sounds like you have a little more going on that you could probably alleviate with some practice and perseverance. Unfortunately, unless you're starting your own band and are the band leader/owner, if you're struggling on all those things you'll find it hard to land a steady gig with a serious group, let alone keep it. 

But put a little effort in and you can change that. You'll get frustrated along the way, you'll hate yourself every once in a while, and you'll want to just quit. But tough it out. You can get there.

As a Gigging Musician: How Often Do You Still Make Mistakes? (Answering a User Question)

A thread came up the other day where a user asked a question, and I thought it was a great one to share... The user asked: "How Often D...